Understanding Christian Nationalism

The term Christian Nationalism has become a significant talking point in today’s cultural and political conversations, yet understanding its implications and differences from Christianity as a faith tradition is crucial. As someone committed to exploring faith inclusively, I want to unravel what this concept means and highlight why distinguishing it from the core of Christianity matters, especially as we seek a more loving, just, and holistic faith experience.

What Is Christian Nationalism?

Christian Nationalism is a worldview that merges national identity with Christian identity. It asserts that America should be defined as a distinctly Christian nation and that its laws, leaders, and institutions should reflect that. At its core, it insists on a fusion of faith and patriotism, often prioritizing a version of Christianity that upholds specific cultural norms and political goals.

This ideology doesn’t merely call for a society influenced by Christian values like love, justice, and compassion; instead, it advocates for a nation-state that privileges Christianity above all other faiths or worldviews, framing it as essential for true national identity.

Where Christian Nationalism and Christianity Diverge

To truly understand the divergence, we must look at what Christianity emphasizes versus what Christian Nationalism promotes.

1. The Emphasis on Power vs. the Way of Jesus

• Christian Nationalism: Often centers on political power, using the language of faith to justify control over cultural and legislative systems. This focus can lead to an “us vs. them” mentality, where other religious or secular identities are seen as threats to a Christian-led nation.

• Christianity: At its heart, Christianity calls for humble, sacrificial love. Jesus himself rejected the pursuit of political power, instead advocating for serving the marginalized, loving enemies, and laying down one’s life for others. The Gospels emphasize a kingdom “not of this world,” which subverts power structures in favor of radical love and grace.

  
  

2. Identity Rooted in Nation vs. Identity Rooted in God’s Kingdom

• Christian Nationalism: Suggests that one’s national identity and Christian faith are inseparable, elevating the nation’s success and prosperity as divine imperatives. Patriotism becomes a spiritual mandate, sometimes overshadowing the global and inclusive nature of the Gospel.

• Christianity: Invites believers to see themselves as citizens of God’s kingdom first and foremost. This identity transcends borders, embracing a vision of unity that includes “every nation, tribe, people, and language” (Revelation 7:9). It’s a call to remember that God’s love and redemption extend far beyond any one country.

  
  

3. Exclusive vs. Inclusive Faith

• Christian Nationalism: Often promotes an exclusionary vision, where Christianity’s role in public life may come at the expense of religious freedom and equal rights for non-Christians. There’s a prioritization of policies and symbols that reinforce a narrowly defined cultural Christianity.

• Christianity: At its best, Christianity embodies an inclusive and welcoming faith, as demonstrated by Jesus’ radical inclusivity. The way of Christ breaks down dividing walls (Ephesians 2:14), inviting all to the table, regardless of background or belief.

  
  

Why This Distinction Matters

As a digital faith community committed to widening the door of the church and creating spaces for exploration, it’s vital to understand how Christian Nationalism can distort Jesus's message. Instead of aligning with the Gospel’s call to love, serve, and stand in solidarity with the oppressed, Christian Nationalism risks conflating discipleship with dominance and power.

We need to ask ourselves: Does our faith inspire us to advocate for justice and peace for all people, or does it lead us to protect our own power and privilege at the expense of others?

The way of Jesus invites us to choose the former, prioritizing compassion, humility, and a love that knows no boundaries.

Moving Forward

Our goal is not to vilify those who may be drawn to Christian Nationalist ideals but to lovingly and thoughtfully call for a faith rooted in Christ's radical teachings. May we seek to embody a Christianity that prioritizes spiritual transformation over political conquest and welcomes everyone to experience God's life-changing love.

In our ongoing journey of faith, let’s continue to question, explore, and rediscover what it means to follow Jesus faithfully in a world longing for hope and healing.

Journal Prompt: Does your faith inspire you to advocate for justice and peace for all people?